Q&A: Things to bake into peanut butter cookies to make them awesome?

Question by Imaginary F: Things to bake into peanut butter cookies to make them awesome?
Got a package of peanut butter cookie mix. What can I bake into the cookies to make them awesome?
ACk! When you make peanut butter cookies it is best not to read the directions off the oatmeal raisin package. I used 1 stick of butter instead of 3 tablespoons of oil and 1 of water. Are they going to turn out?

Best answer:

Answer by Not Rep or Dem!!

Add your own answer in the comments!

  1. Jackie says:

    Nuts of any kind.

  2. BeeJ says:

    Marshmallows or Chocolate Mmmmm……I love that combo!

  3. Audi says:

    take a wad of the peanut butter cookie and roll it around bite size reese’s peanut butter cups.

  4. cod4grrl says:


  5. 'lil peanut says:

    m&ms plain

  6. The Snow Man says:

    I have to say, being from the United Kingdom in England.

    When I went through the USA on the way to Canada and I ate a peanut butter chocolate cookie; I thought it was vile.

    Snow Man

  7. A A says:

    Chocolate chips
    Mini marshmallows
    Chopped walnuts

  8. veganx says:


  9. sue d says:


  10. stanwshura says:

    Well – since they’re already peanut butter cookies, I’m guessing anything is “fair game”.

    Walnuts? Pecans? Macedamia nuts? Mmmm!

    Okay, or there’s M&Ms, chocolate chips?

    I wonder how a little marshmallow fluff or softened butterscotch morsels or even a drizzle of melted hard/bakers chocolate in the mix prior to baking…?

    Oh, ‘scuse me! Gotta wipe the drool off of my keyboard! ;)

  11. skeeter says:

    white chocolate chips, macadamia nuts, Miniature Reece’s cup in middle, M & M, or while cookie is warm make a thumb print filled with strawberry jam

Leave a Reply to A A

Click here to cancel reply.   Some XHTML allowed.